Rethinking Terror and Horror with Plato, Aristotle, and Shakespeare

Jacek Mydla

doi:10.26485/ZRL/2025/68.1/25

Autor

Jacek Mydla University of Silesia, Faculty of Humanities, Institute of Literary Studies https://orcid.org/0000-0003-1240-286X

DOI:

https://doi.org/10.26485/ZRL/2025/68.1/25

Słowa kluczowe:

fear/terror/horror in literature and philosophy; drama; katharsis; Gothic

Abstrakt

This article addresses a blank spot in Gothic studies and in studies of ways in which literature purveys terror, horror, and fear. In the last decades, Gothic studies, including Jacek Mydla’s book, have broadened their scope of research by including Shakespeare’s influence on Gothic romance and drama in eighteenth-century England. Shakespeare’s handling of the ghosts in Hamlet and Macbeth offered Gothicists artistic models of handling terror, especially its supernatural variety: the ghost. While such research on the Gothic broadens our understanding of the genre’s development in its historical and cultural context, it fails to place terror within a comprehensive ethic. Edmund Burke’s theory of the sublime is notoriously deficient in this respect, similarly to an aesthetic that conceives terror as mind-expanding or merely entertaining. Pursuing Horace Walpole’s reference, in the preface to the first edition of The Castle of Otranto, to the cathartic emotions of terror and pity, Mydla explores two interrelated contexts: Plato’s critique of Homer’s representations of terrors of death and the after-life and Plato’s fashioning of Socrates as a philosophical role model in opposition to the impassioned heroism of Achilles. Mydla argues that such “ancient” recontextualising, where Plato’s critique and Aristotle’s insights are related to lessons from Shakespeare’s handling of terror and horror in Hamlet, has the potential to enrich contemporary critical reflection.

Liczba pobrań

Bibliografia

Aristotle (1987), The Poetics, trans. S. Halliwell, The University of North Carolina Press, Chapel Hill.

Aristotle (2009), The Nicomachean Ethics, trans. D. Ross, Oxford University Press, Oxford– New York.

Aristotle (2018), The Art of Rhetoric, trans. R. Waterfield, Oxford University Press, Oxford.

Asmis Elizabeth (2022), Plato on Poetic Creativity: A Revision [in:] The Cambridge Companion to Plato, 2nd ed., eds. D. Ebrey, R. Kraut, Cambridge University Press, Cambridge.

Baillie Joanna (2001), Plays on the Passions [1798], Broadview Press Ltd, Peterborough–New York.

Baillie Joanna (2007), Six Gothic Dramas, selected and introduced Ch.A. Colón, Valancourt Books, Chicago.

Belfiore Elizabeth (1992), Tragic Pleasures: Aristotle on Plot and Emotion, Princeton University Press, Princeton, NJ [e-book].

Bloom Harold (1999), Shakespeare: The Invention of the Human, Fourth Estate, London.

Botting Fred (1999), Gothic, Routledge, London–New York.

Burke Edmund (1998), A Philosophical Enquiry into the Origin of our Ideas of the Sublime and Beautiful, Oxford University Press, Oxford.

Burnyeat M.F. (1997), Culture and Society in Plato’s Republic, “The Tanner Lectures on Human Values”, Harvard University, December 10–12, https://tannerlectures.utah.edu/_resources/documents/a-to-z/b/Burnyeat99.pdf [access: 20.05.2025].

Calderwood James L. (1983), To Be and Not to Be: Negation and Metadrama in “Hamlet”, Columbia University Press, New York.

Clery E.J., Miles Robert (eds.) (2000), Gothic Documents: A Sourcebook 1700–1820, Manchester University Press, Manchester–New York.

Dover Wilson John (1970), What Happens in “Hamlet”, 3rd ed., University Press, Cambridge [1st edition published in 1935; 3rd in 1951].

Drakakis John, Townshend Dale (eds.) (2008), Gothic Shakespeares, Routledge, Abingdon.

Fowler Robert (ed.) (2004), The Cambridge Companion to Homer, Cambridge University Press, Cambridge.

Halliwell Stephen (1984), Plato and Aristotle on the denial of tragedy, “Proceedings of the Cambridge Philological Society” vol. 30.

Halliwell Stephen (1998), Aristotle’s Poetics, Duckworth, London.

Halliwell Stephen (2002), The Aesthetics of Mimesis: Ancient Texts and Modern Problems, Princeton University Press, Princeton, NJ.

Halliwell Stephen (2007), The Life-and-Death Journey of the Soul: Interpreting the Myth of Er [in:] The Cambridge Companion to Plato’s “Republic”, ed. G.R.F. Ferrari, Cambridge University Press, Cambridge.

Halliwell Stephen (2015), Fiction [in:] A Companion to Ancient Aesthetics, eds. P. Destrée, P. Murray, John Wiley & Sons, Inc., Hoboken, NJ.

Havelock Eric A. (1963), Preface to Plato, The Belknap Press of Harvard University Press, Cambridge, MA–London.

Hesiod (2008), Theogony and Works and Days, trans. M.L. West, Oxford University Press, Oxford.

Hobbs Angela (2000), Plato and the Hero: Courage, Manliness and the Impersonal Good, Cambridge University Press, Cambridge.

Hogle Jerrold E. (ed.) (2002), The Cambridge Companion to Gothic Fiction, Cambridge University Press, Cambridge.

Hogle Jerrold E. (ed.) (2014), The Cambridge Companion to the Modern Gothic, Cambridge University Press, Cambridge.

Hogle Jerrold E., Miles Robert (eds.) (2019), The Gothic and Theory: An Edinburgh Companion, Edinburgh University Press, Edinburgh.

Homer (1991), The Iliad, trans. R. Fagles, Penguin, London.

Homer (2006), The Odyssey, trans. R. Fagles, 3rd ed., Penguin, London.

Hunter Richard (2004), Homer and Greek literature, The Cambridge Companion to Homer, ed. R. Fowler, Cambridge University Press, Cambridge.

James M.R. (2011), Collected Ghost Stories, Oxford University Press, Oxford.

Johnson Samuel (2008), The Major Works, Oxford University Press, Oxford.

Lear Jonathan (1988), Katharsis, “Phronesis” vol. 33(3).

Leighton Stephen (2009), Passions and Persuasion [in:] A Companion to Aristotle, ed. G. Anagnostopoulos, Blackwell Publishing Ltd., Malden, MA–Oxford.

Moss Jessica (2007), What Is Imitative Poetry and Why Is It Bad? [in:] The Cambridge Companion to Plato’s “Republic”, ed. G.R.F. Ferrari, Cambridge University Press, Cambridge.

Mydla Jacek (2009), Spectres of Shakespeare: Appropriations of Shakespeare in the Early English Gothic, Wydawnictwo Uniwesytetu Śląskiego, Katowice.

Mydla Jacek (2012), Fear: aestheticised/anaesthetised [in:] Civilisation and Fear: Anxiety and the Writing of the Subject, eds. W. Kalaga, A. Kliś, Cambridge Scholars Publishing, Newcastle upon Tyne.

Mydla Jacek (2015), Old-Type Hauntings by New Ghosts? Word and Image in the ‘Cybernatural Horror’ Unfriended, “in esse: English Studies in Albania. Journal of the Albanian Association for the Study of English (ASSE)” vol. 6(1) [printed in 2017].

Mydla Jacek (2016), Horror czy kpina? Groza, humor i demony przeszłości w opowieściach niesamowitych M.R. Jamesa [Horror or Mockery? Terror, Humour and Demons of the Past in M.R. James’s Weird Stories] [in:] HistoRisus. Historie śmiechu / śmiech [w] historii [Histories of Laughter/Laughter in/of History], eds. R. Borysławski, J. Jajszczok, J. Wolff, A. Bemben, Wydawnictwo Uniwersytetu Śląskiego, Katowice.

Mydla Jacek (2023), Narrating the Ghost: Readings in the Gothic and M.R. James, Wydawnictwo Uniwersytetu Śląskiego, Katowice.

O’Connor David K. (2007), Rewriting the Poets in Plato’s Characters [in:] The Cambridge Companion to Plato’s “Republic”, ed. G.R.F. Ferrari, Cambridge University Press, Cambridge.

Oxford English Dictionary. OED online [2025, February], www.oed.com/?tl=true [access: 20.05.2025].

Nehamas Alexander (1988), Plato and the Mass Media, “The Monist” vol. 71.

Petraki Zacharoula (2021), Hero-cult in Plato’s “Phaedo”, “Republic” and the “Laws”, “Synthesis” vol. 28(2), DOI: 10.24215/1851779xe106.

Plato (2003), The Last Days of Socrates: Euthyphro, Apology, Crito, Phaedo, trans. H. Tredennick, H. Tarrant, Penguin, London.

Plato (2005), Early Socratic Dialogues, trans. T.J. Saunder et al., Penguin, London.

Plato (2007), The Republic, trans. D. Lee, 2nd ed., Penguin Books, London.

Punter David (2013), The Literature of Terror. A History of Gothic Fictions from 1765 to the Present Day, vol. 1. The Gothic Tradition, vol. 2. The Modern Gothic, 2nd ed., Routledge, London–New York.

Shakespeare William (2021), Hamlet, The Arden Shakespeare/Bloomsbury, London.

Samuel Johnson’s Dictionary. Johnson’s Dictionary Online [2025, February], https://johnsonsdictionaryonline.com [access: 20.05.2025].

Vickers Brian (1979), Towards Greek Tragedy, Longman, London.

Walpole Horace (1998), The Castle of Otranto, Oxford University Press, Oxford [originally published 1764/1765].

Webb Timothy (2004), Homer and the Romantics [in:] The Cambridge Companion to Homer, ed. R. Fowler, Cambridge University Press, Cambridge

Woodruff, Paul (2009), Aristotle’s Poetics: The Aim of Tragedy [in:] A Companion to Aristotle, ed. G. Anagnostopoulos, Blackwell Publishing Ltd, Malden.

Young Charles M. (2009), Courage [in:] A Companion to Aristotle, ed. G. Anagnostopoulos, Blackwell Publishing Ltd, Malden.